Search
logo

Golden Gate Salmon Association

  • Home
  • Salmon Under Assault
    • The Problem
    • The Solution
    • Golden Gate Salmon Rebuilding Plan
  • About GGSA
    • Why We Work For Salmon
    • Mission
    • Things You Should Know
    • Board of Directors
    • Executive Committee
    • Contact Us
    • Our Partners
  • Accomplishments
    • Accomplishments 2017-2018
    • Salmon Rebuilding Plan Progress and Accomplishments:  February 2017
    • 2016 Accomplishments
    • 2016 GGSA Press Highlights
    • Accomplishments 2013 – 2015
  • Support GGSA
    • Become a Member
    • Sign Salmon Declaration
    • Take Action
    • Make a Donation
    • 2019 GGSA Sonoma County Dinner of the Year!
  • Fish Tales
    • Fish Tales Newsletter
    • Fish Tales Q4 2018
    • Fish Tales – July 2018
    • Fish Tales – April 2018
    • Fish Tales – Oct. 2017
    • Fish Tales – July 2017
    • Fish Tales – April 2017
    • Fish Tales – Jan. 2017
    • Fish Tales – Oct. 2016
    • Fish Tales – June 2016
    • Fish Tales – March 2016
    • Fish Tales – July 2015
    • Fish Tales – December 2015
    • Fish Tales – September 2015
    • Fish Tales – August 2014
GGSA in the News

How California’s water wars divided one of the closest friendships in Congress

Sens. Barbara Boxer and Dianne Feinstein of California appear with other Democrats at a campaign event for Hillary Clinton last year. (Melina Mara/The Washington Post)

A bill that stands to help farmers struggling through California’s epic drought sits on President Obama’s desk, awaiting a signature that would allow water in a river delta where fish stocks are depleted to be diverted for the state’s parched agriculture.

The story of how the legislation reached the White House reflects the drama of water wars that have pitted groups within California against one another in a fight to survive. The battle over the bill has also divided two of the closest friends and Democratic allies on Capitol Hill, California Sens. Barbara Boxer and Dianne Feinstein.

Their split made headlines this month, given their interwoven history: The pair entered the Senate together 24 years ago in the “Year of the Woman” advance that tripled the number of that chamber’s female members. Over the past quarter-century, even as they became two of the most powerful women on the Hill, Boxer and Feinstein have agreed on virtually every issue that came before them.

Then came the water legislation, which the Senate passed a week ago. Boxer had worked on it for two years as a ranking Democrat on the Environment and Public Works Committee. Shortly before its full vote, Feinstein suddenly pushed forward a 90-page rider that would send greater amounts of river water to farms. In the end, Boxer felt she was forced to campaign against her own measure.

[A giant reservoir that supplies a California county’s drinking water is nearly empty]

“It was heartbreaking,” she said several days ago, in the first remarks either lawmaker has offered in how the fight over farmers and fish came between them. Feinstein termed the standoff “very difficult for me.”

For many Californians, few issues are more rancorous than those involving water. It is the state’s lifeblood, more so than Hollywood, beaches or freeways. It sustains one of the world’s richest economies and is all but worshiped. And with the historic drought entering a sixth year, with residents being called on to conserve even more and farms shriveling, water has become even more precious.

The drought is causing an environmental nightmare. There are now forests of dead trees. Thirsty animals have begun emerging from the woods and venturing into towns and cities in search of a drink. Fish cannot reach the Pacific because large swaths of rivers have gone dry.

Young salmon are loaded onto trucks at the Coleman National Fish Hatchery in Anderson, Calif., to be driven to the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, an effort forced by the state’s historic drought. (Andreas Fuhrmann/Redding, Calif., Record Searchlight via AP)

Humans enjoy nearly every drop of water in the state, but a fraction is set aside for fish. Guided by biological science that determines how much water anadromous fish need to reach the ocean, federal and state officials release amounts at specific times as part of the Endangered Species Act. A $1.4 billion commercial and recreational fishing industry in part depends on their action.

But Boxer said in an interview that language in Feinstein’s rider would allow officials to ignore the science and send more water to farmers — who already use 80 percent of the state’s supply — than the act allows. With the rider attached, she was forced to speak against her own bill. “It was an out-of-body experience,” she said.

Feinstein countered in a separate interview Thursday that diverting water doesn’t kill nearly as many salmon and smelt as other problems in rivers that the rider seeks to fix, such as water polluted by sewer system outflows and invasive species that prey on scores of young fish.

[Wild animals in the drought stricken West are dying for a drink]

Drought has to be addressed not just for fish but for people in a state that has changed considerably since its water system was established in the 1960s, Feinstein said. “It was built . . . when the state was 16 million people. We’ve got 41 million people now.”

Nearly every state association for fisheries opposed Feinstein, as did just about every major newspaper in editorials. Growers sided with her, saying thousands of jobs and crops that feed much of America are being lost to save fish.

Agriculture has fought court-sanctioned scientific opinion that has restricted pumping more water to farms for nearly a decade, said John McManus, executive director of the Golden Gate Salmon Association. “And with this rider by Feinstein, they’ve finally won.”

McManus said he fears his industry will return to the days when salmon fisheries were shut down to help the depleted stock recover.

“We just lost our protections,” he said.

Tom Nassif, president and chief executive of the Western Growers Association, sees the recent vote differently. When rains fell and the rivers filled, federal officials who control river flows allowed excess water that farms could have used to flow to the ocean. “It’s not our intention to endanger animals,” he said, but “we’ve had to fallow a lot of land, the cost of water keeps going up, and we are losing jobs, crops, and farms are having to consolidate. I think the facts prove they send more water to the ocean than what’s necessary.”

Not surprisingly, environmental groups side with Boxer. Peter Gleick, a scientist at the Pacific Institute, said, “This is really a fight between the old way of dealing with water problems in California and the new way we have to tackle them. The old way was to take all the water we need for humans and screw the fish.”

Circle G Farms owner Christopher Hurd walks through a grove of pistachio trees at his farm in Firebaugh, Calif. Farmers struggling with drought in the state’s Central Valley got none of the water they requested from a federally controlled water system. (David Paul Morris/Bloomberg)

“The little bit of water that legal decisions have set aside for the fish isn’t enough; everybody understands that. It’s true that other things are hurting the fish as Feinstein says; everyone understands that,” Gleick said. “But you can’t take more water from the fish and think that’s going to solve the problem.”

In the interview, Boxer continued to call Feinstein “my friend, my colleague, my pal,” but added, “A poison pill rider that drops on a beautiful bill at the last minute is why people hate Congress. It’s the way people do things when they can’t stand up to the regular order.

“If Senator Feinstein is saying this is the way to do business, I would say I disagree with that strongly,” Boxer continued. The rider “never had a hearing. It never even went to my committee because it’s in the jurisdiction of the Energy Committee. That’s not the way to legislate in my opinion. It’s not right to have not one hearing.”

Feinstein has long been a friend of farmers and delivering water to them is an issue that has separated the two lawmakers before. Aides to Feinstein said she has spoken with bankrupted growers who broke down in tears because their farms no longer produced.

[Showers and toilets went dry when this California county ran out of water]

As Boxer searched for a way to fix infrastructure and clean water, Feinstein looked for ways to deliver water to thirsty fields. She said her staff relied on research and marathon discussions with scientists at the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, as well as other agencies in the Commerce and Interior departments, to craft the language they inserted.

Aides to Feinstein said California water issues are difficult to legislate and are often resolved at the last minute. They said the rider includes endangered-species protections for fish that must be enforced by law, and they maintain that fish and the state’s ecosystem won’t suffer for farmers. But the bill also gives the Commerce and Interior secretaries in President-elect Donald Trump’s administration more say in how much water should be diverted to California farmers, who overwhelming supported the Republican nominee.

“That sort of discretion might have been tolerable if entrusted to cabinet members of an environmentally responsible administration,” a recent Los Angeles Times editorial noted, “but it must be seen in a different light with a White House with a decidedly different approach to the environment.”

Boxer is about to retire, but Feinstein’s current term continues through 2018. “I’m going to fight like a lion to see this bill is carried out as intended,” she said.

The two senators agree on one thing. “There are other issues that can be addressed and must be addressed when it comes to protecting fish,” Boxer said. “However, this is the elephant in the room, how much water these fish have.

“This is a clear issue. Does it hurt the fishing industry? Does it injure the environment of California? This isn’t personal,” Boxer said. “This is who’s hurt by this.”

You Might Like

2019 GGSA Santa Rosa Dinner Party of the Year!

Bay Area Salmon Advocates Decry Proposed Delta Water Diversions

Trump to name acting Interior secretary, a former oil and gas lobbyist-lawyer, to lead department

Previous Post
President Obama Signs Water Bill With Big Ag ‘Poison Pill’ Rider
Next Post
Think Tank Urges Fresh Look at the Delta Water Tunnel Plan

Donate Now

GGSA in the News

  • Bay Area Salmon Advocates Decry Proposed Delta Water Diversions

    Bay City News Service Published 12:13 am PST, Friday, February 8, 2019 Officials from a San Francisco-based group dedicated to preserving the region’s salmon habitat say a new federal plan to divert…

GGSA Social

GGSA Facebook

View on Facebook

Golden Gate Salmon Association added 3 new photos.
Golden Gate Salmon Association
Yesterday GGSA founder Victor Gonella received the Salmon Conservation Lifetime Acheivement Award. He also received recognition from the CA State Legislature and the US Congress. First photo, Victor (center), GGSA president John McManus (left) and GGSA chairman and West Marine Founder Randy Repass (right) with award plaque. Second photo, Victor and State Legislature Resolution, third photo, Victor and US Congressional Record. … See MoreSee Less

Message Page

Yesterday GGSA founder Victor Gonella received the Salmon Conservation Lifetime Acheivement Award.  He also received recognition from the CA State Legislature and the US Congress.  First photo, Victor (center), GGSA president John McManus (left) and GGSA chairman and West Marine Founder Randy Repass (right) with award plaque. Second photo, Victor and State Legislature Resolution, third photo, Victor and US Congressional Record.Image attachmentImage attachment

  • Likes: 33
  • Shares: 4
  • Comments: 4

 

Comment on Facebook

Great event for a wonderful and great man! A leader and visionary! Thank you Victor for championing Salmon!

very well deserved honor...and a great fisherman!

Congratulations

Heckuva a guy. Great job recognizing his contribution to a great organization.

Golden Gate Salmon Association
Golden Gate Salmon Association
CDFW has issued strong flow requirements for the Sacramento River before water could be diverted to the proposed Sites Reservoir. Important for them to hold the line and not agree to weaker standards. No doubt the big water users are pounding on Gov. Newsom to back away from these. Please don’t. see www.sacbee.com/news/state/california/water-and-drought/article225944195.html … See MoreSee Less
Link thumbnail

Sites Reservoir is Sacramento Valley’s water project. But L.A. is taking a huge role

sacbee.com

Sites Reservoir was heralded as the Sacramento Valley’s answer to California water problems. But the Metropolitan Water District of Southern California is taking on a bigger role.

  • Likes: 9
  • Shares: 17
  • Comments: 3

 

Comment on Facebook

So how fast could the Sites Reservoir be filled with the current storm flows going down the Sacramento River?

How can I get tickets to March 1 fundraiser at Marin Rod club?

Westlands Water District Is also a small player in Sites reservoir. But the overall effect, if MWD, was able to secure its full allocation of 50K Acre feet, would still leave 1.75M Acre feet available! And as the states own findings, the environmental benefits to the fish(through more cold water releases thru Shasta) would be significantly better than current practices.

Load more

About The GGSA
GGSA’s mission is to restore California’s largest salmon runs in the Central Valley rivers because they provide the bulk of salmon caught off our coast and inland rivers. We serve the sport and commercial anglers that rely on salmon as a long-term, sustainable resource. Salmon recovery is our passion.

GGSA is a coalition that includes commercial and recreational salmon fishermen, related businesses, restaurants, a native tribe, environmentalists, elected officials, families, and communities that rely on salmon GGSA has a board comprised of representatives of this diverse community, which reaches from Oregon to the Central Coast, through the Bay-Delta and up a dozen rivers in the Central Valley.
GGSA on Instagram
  • You don’t want to miss this party! Get your tickets now.
  • Stop into the Pavilion building (booth 3716), at #internationalsportsmansexpo and say hi to the GGSA folks that are working everyday to protect and restore our salmon population now, and for our future generations.  #supportggsa
  • Thank you @saltyladysportfishing for the great ‘office’ space today! #saveCAsalmon #salmon #fishing #boardmembers #meetingsonaboat
  • GGSA shows up at SF protest of Sen. Feinstein’s support for diverting even more salmon water to almond growers in the western San Joaquin Valley.
  • The upper Sac is still producing some nice ones.  Helps to fish with Fishing guide Mike Bogue!  These were caught before the last storm.
  • Crab feed, Alice Collective, Oakland benefit for GGSA.  Thanks! #crab #alicecollective #goldengatesalmonassociation
  • Flock of plovers(?) on the beach after the storm.
  • Yum, a bucket of fresh salmon eggs.  Some of these will turn into 20 pound fish on the back deck of the boat a few years from now.
  • Big king salmon beating down the doors to get back into the Mokelumne hatchery where they cane from three years ago.

Follow GGSA on Instagram!

Save Salmon Now
Search the site
Archives